Saturday, 18 October 2008

Manchester United 4-0 West Bromwich Albion

A second half masterclass from Wayne Rooney inspired Manchester United to a flattering 4-0 scoreline over Tony Mowbray's West Brom at Old Trafford.

The result catapults United into the top 4 for the first time this season and underlines the growth in confidence and influence embodied by Rooney - scorer of one and maker of two others, as Cristiano Ronaldo and Dimitar Berbatov struggled to have any say on proceedings.

A first half with plenty of hustle but no real quality - aside from Rooney - saw United at times struggle against the sheer numbers the Baggies packed into midfield. In the stand out moment, Rooney had a goal disallowed rather harshly for a push, then a minute later almost heading in a Giggs cross.

Rafael, making his first Premiership start, played well enough but in Chris Brunt he had a lively foe - Patrice Evra's injury and subsequent replacement by John O'Shea just before the break more or less ended any full back threat. This just spurred Rooney into action 10 minutes after the break, latching onto a Ronaldo pass, superbly cutting across defender Donk, and firing in a low shot at the near post.

With 20 minutes to go Rooney returned the favour, playing a magnificent pass to Ronaldo who slotted home coolly. A couple of minutes later and the frustrated Berbatov pounced to slot home a Nani corner that was poorly defended. It was his first league goal for United, and at the Stretford End to boot, but his lack of celebration would have done nothing to endear himself to United fans who still wait to be convinced that the lanky Bulgarian deserves to start in front of fan favourite Carlos Tevez.

And, with a couple of minutes left on the clock, Nani himself became the final beneficiary of Rooney's superb work, tapping in the mercurial Englishman's cross goal pass.

Ratings: van der Sar 7, Rafael 7 (Neville 6) , Ferdinand 7, Vidic 7, Evra (O'Shea 6), Ronaldo 7, Fletcher 6, Giggs 7, Park 6 (Nani 7), *Rooney 9, Berbatov 6.

Tuesday, 7 October 2008

Blackburn Rovers 0 - 2 Manchester United

Goals from Wes Brown and Wayne Rooney secured three points for United at Ewood Park.

In all fairness it could have been more as Darren Fletcher and then Ryan Giggs were provided by great passes for Berbatov and were agonisingly close, even before the first goal. It was the Giggs shot that led to the first goal, Rooney delivering the corner and Wes Brown squeezing in the header at the far post. Rovers keeper Jason Brown appealed for a foul by Vidic but there was nothing doing.

Despite Blackburns undoubted effort, and the perennial business of striker Santa Cruz, they never managed to create anything of note - ensuring a third clean sheet in a row and a huge compliment to the back four who managed to keep their composure in terrible weather conditions.

Cristiano Ronaldo, who had previously come to life in fits and starts, provided the breakthrough to seal the game after a hour, with a blistering run on the right hand, pulling the ball back for Rooney who showed supreme control to guide the shot into the top corner.

It was just reward for United, and they could have scored again soon after, Ronaldo setting up Tevez in an almost identical position to Rooney, but the Argentina forward found the post.

Sir Alex Ferguson must have been delighted by the performance, and equally thrilled at the sight of such stunning composure and technical ability in the conditions. The result puts United within 3 points of Chelsea.

Ratings : van der Sar 7, Brown 8, Ferdinand 8, Vidic 8, Evra 7 (O'Shea 6), Ronaldo 8, Anderson 7, Giggs 7 (Tevez 7), *Rooney 8 (Park), Berbatov 8.

Tuesday, 30 September 2008

Aalborg 0 -3 Manchester United

Aalborg 0 - 3 Manchester United

Dimitar Berbatov's first two Manchester United goals sealed a comfortable Champions League away win in Denmark.

Berbatov had squandered a fantastic chance to put the European Champions ahead but when Ryan Giggs - on for the injured Paul Scholes - played a superb pass to Wayne Rooney, the Englishman made no mistake to put United ahead. The Bulgarian did score his first goal for the club soon after half time after an almighty cock up by the Aalborg skipper - Berbatov half volleyed in from 20 yards to a feeling of almost disbelief.

His second was similar in technique but owed less to defensive inability and more to the quality of Ronaldo's wingplay, and United were settled.

Berbatov repaid the favour to Ronaldo moments later but the Portguese wizard could not find the net. Injuries to the very impressive Rafael and Rooney soured proceedings, but the scoreline reflected a very impressive away performance.

Ratings : van der Sar 7, Rafael 8 (Brown 7), Ferdinand 8, Vidic 7, Evra 7, Ronaldo 8, O'Shea 6, Scholes (Giggs 8), Rooney 8 (Tevez 7), *Berbatov 8

Saturday, 27 September 2008

Manchester United 2 - 0 Bolton Wanderers

First league goals of the season for both Cristiano Ronaldo and substitute Wayne Rooney gave Manchester United their first home league win of the season.

In a curious but goalless first half, Bolton started and finished the stronger - sandwiching a 20 minute spell where they were camped inside their own half. For all the possession of the ball they had (81% in the first half), United couldn't find the net - plenty of speculative efforts were attempted - around a dozen - but a header from Berbatov, a drive from Anderson, a shot from Ferdinand and a freekick by Ronaldo were all saved by Bolton keeper Jaaskaleinen, and a Park rebound from a Tevez drive could only find the side of the net. And it was Bolton who had the best chance of the opening half when Muamba somehow fired a late shot wide.

Wanderers started the second half with the same kind of purpose and went close again, before United hit back with Ronaldo hitting the post from 15 yards.

In the 58th minute referee Rob Styles had a 3 minute spell of madness. Firstly, after waving play on after a foul by Tevez, Bolton decided not to - Styles allowed them to go back and take the free kick. Then, seconds later, Ronaldo broke with the ball in the box, and was challenged by J'Lloyd Samuel. It was a fantastic challenge, but Styles gave a penalty - despite the lack of appeal by Unirted players. No blame could be attached to the often criticised Ronaldo, and the Portguese winger accepted the gift of a goal to break the deadlock.

The penalty was fortunate in more ways than one - despite dominating the game the home side seemed to have two problems - penetration and delivery of dead balls. The first problem was sorted on around 70 minutes, when Wayne Rooney and Paul Scholes took to the field, and instantly United looked more purposeful in the attacking third, especially Rooney, who was superb in his cameo.

It took Rooney just 6 minutes to score, combining well with a 1-2 with Ronaldo before beautifully curling into the corner. The striker then set about trying to get a goal for Dimitar Berbatov but wasn't successful - the introduction of Nani for Ronaldo saw Nani go for goal whenever possible, disrupting some magnificent football in the last 20 minutes.

Ratings : van der Sar 7, Neville 7, Ferdinand 8, Vidic 7, Evra 8, Ronaldo 8 (Nani 7), Anderson 7 (Scholes 8), Fletcher 7, Park 6, Tevez 7 (Rooney 8*), Berbatov 7

Tuesday, 23 September 2008

Ryan Giggs - the greatest of all time?

With Monday's release of the "Ryan Giggs - True Red" DVD, which chronicles his fantastic career, there is a question that surely, at this time, is a fair one - is Ryan Giggs the greatest player ever?

To give the question somewhat of a mathematical context, ability x longevity x achievement could be seen as some fair formula, although ultimately it all comes down to opinion, such is the objectivity that surrounds football.

In doing research for this blog I have to say that I have been persuaded to say "YES" - and I came into it believing that Best, Pele or Maradona was. I expect a few people will think I'm crazy but I will attempt to answer points made for any argument against.

Though his goal tally has often been criticised has not being good enough (143 goals in 745 games), a quick comparison with, say, Steven Gerrard (99 goals in 445), shows that it's a very respectable record considering Gerrard has made a career out of taking penalties, free kicks and generally dropping off the striker. That's not a criticism of Gerrard, by any stretch of the imagination, but more a marker to say how impressive Giggs has been.

Just as impressive is taking account of how many of those 143 have been special - either in the delivery of the goal or the context in importance terms, and indeed, sometimes, both.

Another criticsm that is often levelled at Giggs is that his final delivery wasn't good. Codswallop, in my opinion. He has provided more goals over his career than anyone else in Premier League history, and to this day is capable of providing a pass no-one else can. His slide rule ball is the most undefendable in the entire league, and unexpected moments of class such as the pass for Tevez's goal against Chelsea last season are an indication that intelligence wise, he is on another planet.

Goals at the highest level - well, for every stunning Maradona solo effort, so there is a Giggs replica. For every embarrassed defender Bestie left behind, so, too, there is a Giggs replica. And vital contributions at the most pivotal of times, too. Ryan Giggs has been no fearer of setting or stage - numerous goals to clinch numerous titles for United, numerous semi final strikes to swing the tie, or indeed, entire season's worth of momentum back into United's favour.

Some say he hasn't been consistent enough. The rebuttal is simple - you don't play an integral part in three almost completely different sides, in one of the most phsyically demanding positions, over a period of 17 years if you are a passenger. Sir Alex has shown that by ruthlessly disposing of players when they are considered to no longer have a role to play. In 2006 he was asked, at the age of 32, to play centre midfield with John O'Shea. That United managed to finish 2nd and included a run in where Giggs and O'Shea dominated a much heralded Arsenal midfield was testament to the maturity and fundamental ability of the Welshman. A closer inspection reveals that Giggs' form often reflects the success of United and the overall style of the team.

The destructive pace of the early 90's, the cultured never say die, take on all comers of the late 90's/early 00's, and the current continental, composed magnificent footballing side of today. It is no coincidence that Ryan Giggs, in the autumn of his career, was superb again last winter as United produced some of the finest football in their history.

The final thing people often say about Giggs is that he never achieved anything at International level. But, Puskas and Best never played a major tournament either - and all success is relative. Dunga, coach of the Brazilian national team, said in 2006 after a friendly against Wales that he was glad Giggs wasn't Brazilian as he would give him too big a selection headache. Quite a compliment considering players in the attacking midfield position included a peak condition Ronaldinho and Kaka.

Like Sir Bobby Charlton before him, Giggs will probably only be truly appreciated after he retires - a shame, and an even greater shame that the new breed of fans in todays "must win at all cost" mentality don't appreciate the likes of our current legends and want them to be pushed aside for younger players who may be faster but are naive - tell me that Fabregas or Ronaldo can technically compare with Ryan Giggs and I will laugh in your face. They are simply not capable of doing with a ball what Giggs can.

He may be unappreciated by many fans but not among his contemporaries - "He is the player chosen by God", Luis Figo said of him, while Alex Del Piero says "How could I possibly appraise him? Fantasy star? Yeah, that's Ryan Giggs... this is embarrassing to say but I have cried twice in my life watching football players.. the first was Roberto (Baggio) and the second was Ryan Giggs."

Zidane said, "If he was French I would have been on the bench." This from a man who is considered by most to be the greatest player of his generation, despite having a career that was significantly shorter at the highest level.
Listening to the current crop of players at United you can sense the respect among his peers, especially among the likes of Ferdinand and Rooney.

Below I have highlighted just a few of Giggs' finest goals throughout his career for United, and you will probably be surprised at the extent of the catalogue.

To add to the list, on the 21st May, 2008, Ryan Giggs set a new appearance record for the club, scoring the winning penalty in the European Cup final. That in itself was somewhat of an achievement considering he'd missed his only previous penalty, in a shootout at the Stretford End against Southampton more than 16 years earlier!

His highlights don't start and end with his goals, however. Man of the match performances in Europe during the years of 96-2001 at Old Trafford against the likes of Juventus twice, Porto, Real Madrid, Fiorentina, and Bordeaux, a man of the match display in the Intercontinental Cup setting up the winning goal, those runs that saw him go past 6 or 7 players (notably against Anderlecht and Sunderland) which resulted in penalties, volleying from the halfway line at Charlton which was a crossbar's width away from probably the second greatest goal of all time? The backheel flick around Julian Dicks at Upton Park on the halfway line, before running and crossing for Cantona? Scoring via Ashley Cole in the infamous "I'll see you out there" game? The string of performances in the second half of the 99/2000 season that made him probably the best in Europe at that time? Setting up 4 goals against Roma?

What about the trick he performed against Arsenal in 1993 that I'm not sure even has a name, that I've never seen performed before or since that time? These are just a few memories of the top of my head, I could sit here all day writing them.

The blog is already massive and I haven't even mentioned that all this is from a man who has played his entire career for the club he supported as a boy. He's simply lived the dream, and millions of United fans around the world have lived it with him.

Ryan Giggs had, and still has, the ability to thrill, entertain and wow fans like no other talent in the world.

I may be among a minority of even United fans to believe it, but I'm nailing my colours to mast - Ryan Giggs, you truly are the greatest footballer to have lived.

It was going to be a long night for Ryan

Enjoy the trip down memory lane -

First goal -
Man City 4/5/91 Old Trafford. Was it his? Probably not, but the record shows it.


Norwich - 7/9/91 Old Trafford - skinned the keeper and rolled it in from impossible angle.

West Ham - 23/11/91 - stunning volley.

Boro 11/03/92, OT, semi final clincher in League Cup, volley on difficult angle.

(Scored in two Manchester derby (one dubious, one magnificent from 25 yards), at Boundary Park, Elland Road, a semi final winner, all before being 19.)


19/9/92 Spurs WHL "That goal" skins one, megs another, rounds the keeper, classy finish

28/12/92 - Coventry - magnificent 20 yard curler in top corner

18/01/93 - QPR - Loftus Road - latches onto through ball at speed and showing expert control, lifts it over the keeper from 18 yards

23/01/93 - Brighton - FA Cup - great near post free kick

05/04/03 Norwich - away - in a vital game, Giggs latched onto an early Cantona through ball to score what was becoming a trademark, round the keeper and into the net, to set the tone for a pulsating early show.

03/05/93 Blackburn - 30 yard free kick to celebrate winning the title.


21/08/93 Newcastle - stunning free kick at the Stretford End.

04/01/94 Liverpool - Anfield, Giggs beats a defender and chips Grobellar for an iconic goal.

22/01/94 Everton - Old Trafford - In a game notable for the first after the death of Sir Matt Busby, United put on a great display, creating chance after chance but failing to score - until Giggs met a Keane cross to head brilliantly in.

05/02/94 - QPR - Loftus Road - Giggs skins 4 defenders and coolly finishes to Clive Tyldesley's immortal "the boy's a genius!"

13/02/94 - Sheff Wed - Semi Final 1st leg - defender doesn't deal with it, Giggs races in, rounds keeper, almost on byline at the edge of the box somehow scores.

27/04/94 Leeds away - combines brilliantly with Hughes to score, brilliantly.

01/05/94 - Ipswich away - Giggs almost karate kicks the ball in to all but seal United's second successive title.


14/09/94 - Gothenburg - scores United's first ever "Champions League" group stage goal, then scores the winner.


21/10/95 - Chelsea away - a stunning solo effort at Stamford Bridge, bamboozling the defenders before stabbing home.

18/11/95 - Southampton - Giggs scores United's quickest ever goal, after just 16 seconds, then adds to it a couple of minutes later!

06/04/96 - Citeh (away) - Keith Curle invites him to shoot. Infact, orders him to. Giggs can't score from there, can he? Yep, afraid so. Magnificent 20 yard drive into the top corner.

05/05/96 - Boro away - scores the third in a 3-0 win to seal a third title. A cute strike from 20 yards giving the keeper no chance.


4/12/96 - Rapid Vienna away - our Ryan skins two defenders on halfway, plays it to Eric, runs almost full circle leaving the defender for dead and scores across the keeper from 20 yards to seal Champions League qualification.

18/01/97 - Coventry away- tackles to win a loose ball, regains his balance, and scores beautifully with his right foot from 20 yards to announce to the world "yep.. I have one".

05/03/97 - Porto - not content with running the show from midfield, Giggsy decides he wants a piece of the action and smashes in at the Stretford End to complete a stunning break and amaze English football.


01/10/97 - Juventus. After terrifying the Juve defence all game (prompting Zinedane Zidane to rank it as the greatest first time he'd seen a player play, alongside Ronaldo 9), Giggsy put the icing on the cake by running through and drilling in from 16 yards. Barry Davies exclaimed "Oh! I don't believe that!", and nor could any United fan.

25/10/97 - Barnsley. Carries the ball around 50 yards before effortlessly placing it from 20 yards into the top corner. Oh yeah, with his right foot.


16/09/98 Barcelona - Giggs keeps his composure after watching David Beckham skin and race past his marker (yes, it did happen), to rise above his marker like a salmon (yes, it did happen) and score an unlikely goal. But it did happen.

26/12/98 Nottingham Forest - technically brilliant, chipped finish on the angle to complete a fantastic move between Sheringham and Beckham.

07/04/99 Juventus - last minute equaliser that was lashed into the roof of the net to rescue the tie heading into a fateful tie in Turin.

14/04/99 Arsenal, Villa Park - Do I really need to describe what is probably the best goal of all time? In extra time, carrying a niggle, Giggs is sent on from the bench to "keep the ball" as United are down to ten men. Picking the ball up in his own half he decides to skin the most physically dominating midfielder in the game and then skin the most miserly defence in Europe before finishing with incredible power, scoring the goal that every schoolboy dreams of scoring, the goal that breathed new life into United's season and inspired tired legs. Then celebrated by exposing his hairy chest. Lovely stuff.


18/12/99 - West Ham, Upton Park. Exquisitely flicks the ball to Yorke, collects the return stabbing in. More for the outrageous flick than the goal.


13/01/01 - Bradford, Valley Parade - Giggs shows ridiculously composed control to collect a 30 yard high ball, killing it instantly, then turning his marker inside out before drilling past the keeper via the near post. In my humble opinion, the kind of goal which has been so understated but wouldn't have been if anyone else had scored it.

14/04/01 - Coventry - Scores a 15 yard header in the top corner to seal the title at Easter. Oh yeah, all kinds of goals.

13/05/01 - Southampton away - although in defeat, one of the great solo goals - Giggs beats two men, plays a one two with Yorke, taking two other defenders out, then coolly finishing.


10/04/02 - Deportivo - Fewer sights in football are as great as seeing Giggs put defenders on their arse. He didn't disappoint here, beating another just for good measure, and scoring at the near post. A great European goal.


23/08/02 - Chelsea away - Giggs scores his 100th United goal, tremendously curling from 12 yards in off the crossbar.

25/02/03 - Juventus away - Ryan was getting a bit of unfair stick about his form and answered his critics in typical fashion - scoring 2 at the Delle Alpi, the second a glorious solo effort finished past Buffon with his right foot. As Tyldesley says in commentary "the type that only Ryan Giggs can score".

05/04/03 Liverpool. It'd been 2 years since Giggs last Old Trafford league goal, that title clinching header. What better way to break your duck than scoring in a 4-0 win over the Dippers, arriving late to pounce like a theif in the night, and leaving the Liverpool keeper looking all around him, bemused.

16/04/03 Arsenal away. Giggs had scored in consecutive games against Liverpool and Newcastle and now faced this third in the "title crunch" triple header. And head he did, expertly converting Solskjaer's cross.


16/08/03 Bolton. With Beckham gone, people wondered where United's set piece threat would come from. They needn't have worried. Giggs scored via the post from 25 yards on the opening day to remind everyone about a certain number 11.

09/11/03 Liverpool away. Two goals at the Kop in a United win. The second in off the bar. Nice one.


28/09/04 Fenerbache. In a game probably best remembered for a certain Mr Rooney scoring a goal or two, Giggs got the ball rolling with an expertly taken header from 12 yards - equalling Sir Bobby in the European goal ranks.

28/12/04 Aston Villa away. Another of those underrated gems. Giggs extravagantly flicks a long ball with his heel onto O'Shea. He flicks it back to the Welshman who cuts inside and scores confidently from 20 yards.

26/01/05 Chelsea, League Cup semi. Showing that no amount of money can compensate for sheer class, Giggs scores one of the competitions greatest ever goals, magnificently evading Terry and flicking the ball over Cech on the volley from about 15 yards. Stunner.

07/05/05 - West Brom - quick free kick across goal. Very cute.


11/12/05 - Everton. Latches onto a long Scholes pass to score a similar goal to the Chelsea one. Very, very classy.

26/3/06 - Birmingham. Received a ball from Rio, nutmegged his marker, swapped passes with Rooney, outpacing the entire Brum defence at the age of 32, and scoring with a nice low drive.


26/08/06 Watford - an exhibition of style, composure and great awareness. Giggs beat the offside trap and, in flashes of 1992, nonchalantly skinned the keeper before scoring.

24/02/07 Fulham away. Did he mean it? If so, one of the most brilliant half volleys of all time - on the angle, Giggs rescues United's title hopes. Knowing Giggs, he probably did.


08/12/07 Derby - Ronaldo shoots, keeper spills, Giggs scores rebound. It's the exception to the rule of Giggs' goals generally coming from his own brilliance, but nonetheless, it was his 100th league goal. All for United, of course.

11/05/08 Wigan away - and in typical Giggs fashion, his 101st came on his record equalling appearance for the club, to seal the title on the last day, with all the composure that had become his trademark in his later years.

Sunday, 21 September 2008

Chelsea 1 - 1 Manchester United

Manchester United gained a credible 1-1 draw at Stamford Bridge but will be somewhat frustrated to not have ended Chelsea's four and a half year unbeaten home league run.

Fuelled by criticsm of their lacklustre start to the campaign, United ferociously attacked from the off, taking Chelsea by surprise with both their selection and formation. Darren Fletcher had an early shot blocked and another just wide before Rio Ferdinand galloped up the pitch, collecting a great Wayne Rooney pass but seeing his shot tipped over by Petr Cech.

While the selection of Fletcher and Park may have initially been to combat the attacking force of the Chelsea full backs, United finally got the goal their start deserved in the 18th minute. Patrice Evra collected a superb Rooney through ball and pulled it back for Berbatov - the Bulgarian saw his shot saved by Cech, but Park collected the rebound and kept his composure to slot home.

Edwin van der Sar then took centre stage - looking uncertain at a couple of corners, superbly stopping Malouda when the Frenchman was through, then finally spilling a shot just before the half hour which antagonised an injury picked up from Malouda's challenge. Tomasz Kuszczak replaced the Dutch stopper, and was forced into action to deny Malouda - though the winger was clearly offside, the Polish keeper's save was magnificent, and he had to be alert - Nicolas Anelka was similarly offside earlier in the half but the referee waved play on.

Referee Mike Riley was in nitpicking mood but his decision to book 7 United players (that will bring with it an FA fine) while allowing a number of identical Chelsea challenges to go unpunished will have done little to alter Sir Alex Ferguson's mindset after his recent comments. Chelsea certainly benefitted from the rub of the green from the officials as Riley's constant hounding of Paul Scholes forced Fergie into a change - normally, Ronaldo for Scholes would be seen as a positive move, but given the effectiveness of the formation to that point, you couldn't help but wonder if it would have a negative impact.

For a while the game became end to end - Ronaldo's width causing an extra headache for the home defence, and chances came and went at both ends - Rooney missing United's best after Ronaldo had done brilliantly to pull it back from wide left. Anelka amazingly managed to miss practically an open goal from a Joe Cole pass, as Chelsea pushed.

A Chelsea equaliser seemed inevitable - they threw all their attacking options on, and from a free kick 10 minutes from time, Kalou headed home. Kuszczak may feel he could have done better, instead the keeper stayed rooted to the spot despite the free kick being fully 40 yards out.

Far from deflate United, they stuck to their guns and pushed for a win, which made for an exciting/nervous final 10 minutes - Ronaldo, in the last moments, almost spectacularly won it for the Champions with a 20 yard overhead kick, but in the end, both sides had to settle for a point - a result nobody could argue with but one the travelling support will have cause to lament Riley's performance that was less than equal - particularly in the case of Scholes, whose treatment from the referee was a pivotal scenario, and particularly due to the impressive message United were sending.

Ratings : van der Sar 6 (Kuszczak 6), Neville 7, Ferdinand 8, Evans 8, Evra 8, *Hargreaves 8, Fletcher 8, Scholes 8 (Ronaldo 6), Park 8 (O'Shea), Rooney 8, Berbatov 6.

Thursday, 18 September 2008

Manchester United 0-0 Villareal

Champions League holders Manchester United limped to a miserable scoreless draw against Spanish side Villareal at Old Trafford. The Red Devils, who welcomed back last season's hero and the summers villain, Cristiano Ronaldo, as a substitute, continued to set a trend of unremarkable paralells to their last season as defending European Champions.

Indeed, the only positive to take out of their opening group fixture was that Ronaldo was welcomed to a rapturous applause - but although a draw was a huge anti-climax to the anticipating crowd, at least signs were encouraging, even if in the slightest, from their previous domestic league game.

Ronaldo - welcomed back to a warm Old Trafford applause

United were, realistically, the only team who wanted three points from the fixture, and were denied 2 clear penalties from fouls on Ji Sung Park in the first half. Even after Ronaldo's introduction, chances didn't suddenly materialise - although the Portguese was involved in all three of United's major openings in the second period. First, he headed wide from a cross, second, he played in Rooney, who found Tevez, whose shot was cleared off the line, and finally, his cross was headed onto the post by young Northern Irishman Jonny Evans.

Villareal, in all fairness, got the result they came for - and could have even snatched a win, after a second half backheel hit the post.

Ratings : van der Sar 6, Neville 7, Ferdinand 6, Evans 7, Evra 6, Park 6 (Ronaldo 6), Fletcher 7, Hargreaves 6 (Anderson 6), *Nani 7, Rooney 7, Tevez 6 (Giggs).

Saturday, 13 September 2008

Liverpool 2-1 Manchester United

Liverpool 2 - 1 Manchester United

Liverpool inflicted Manchester United's first league defeat of the season to make it two losses on the bounce for Sir Alex's men who were far from their best.

United started brightly and were already denied a clear penalty for handball before Carlos Tevez put them ahead after just 3 minutes (from a Berbatov assist after a magnificent Anderson flick). But Wes Brown's own goal on 27 minutes and Liverpool substitute Ryan Babel's mis-hit shot on 77 secured a first win for Liverpool in the league at Anfield against the Red Devils since 2001.

In truth, United looked toothless in search of an equaliser despite fielding a forward line of Tevez, Berbatov and Rooney. And the writing was on the wall when two incredible refereeing moments effectively ended any chance of a United comeback.

First, the final substitution for Liverpool was blocked by Rafa Benitez when he jumped on the pitch waving his arms to change his mind - bizarre behaviour that was allowed to occur, as Rafa was pointing to Mascherano, who had apparently pulled up with injury. However, Benitez did not bring Mascherano off, and when United played the ball into the box, the Argentinian dived to win a free kick.

It was simply despicable behaviour by manager and player that was allowed to perform this blatant act of time wasting, and changing a decision after he'd made it.

Referee Howard Webb then saw fit to seal United's fate by sending off Nemanja Vidic for what seemed to be an elbow offence - not by Vidic's action, rather, it was the only offence Webb could possibly have deemed suitable of a second yellow. What made it more incredulous was Jamie Carragher's identical challenge less than a minute later, which was deemed perfectly fair. Vidic will now miss the Chelsea game next week. A big decision all round from Howard Webb which could prove costly for the Champions.

All in all, Liverpool deserved the win - United were lacklustre and should have put the game to rest before Brown's own goal, their opposition were incredibly poor but seemed more up for it on the day.

Ratings : van der Sar 5, Brown 5, Ferdinand 6, Vidic 6, Evra 6, Scholes 5 (Hargreaves 5), Anderson 6 (Nani 5), Carrick 6 (Giggs 6), Rooney 5, *Tevez 6, Berbatov 6.

Friday, 29 August 2008

Manchester United 1-2 Zenit St. Petersburg

UEFA Cup winners Zenit St. Petersburg produced another shock result, typical of their successful campaign last season, but as was the case then, it was a well deserved victory, this time over the European Champions, as the Russian club won the UEFA Super Cup.

Manchester United looked sluggish, and at times lacking in real creativity - with a midfield of Cristiano Ronaldo, Michael Carrick, Owen Hargreaves and Ryan Giggs all unavailable, Sir Alex Ferguson once again called on Darren Fletcher and the jet-setting Anderson, who despite a typically competitive and industrious performance, was clearly showing signs of his around the world excursions in the last 7 days.

Zenit looked much the sharper in the early stages, producing a couple of surges down the right hand side. While their attacks weren't deadly, as such, they served as surprise warning signs for United. A defensive scramble seconds before half time proved vital, and possibly fatal to United's chances of winning the trophy. Pavel Pogrebnyak made amends for screwing a couple of earlier chances, and took advantage of slack defending in the box following a corner to head in on the line from a Denisov flick on.

The second half failed to spark the Red Devils into life, and £24m signing Danny showed why Zenit were prepared to splash the cash when he sealed the victory with a fine solo effort, making mugs, worringly, out of the United defence. Next game Rio and co are up against Fernando Torres who will be keen to atone for a couple of poor shows against the Reds last term - we can only hope any ring rustiness has been shaken off by then.

It wasn't looking much better up front - Nani was ineffectual on his return, and while Carlos Tevez was energetic and the most likely goal source, Wayne Rooney looked shockingly off-key - perhaps letting the media doubters get to him.
At 2-0 Zenit sat back and United produced a late surge - Nemanja Vidic converted Tevez's pull back to reduce the deficit, but an equaliser was never really on the cards. When Paul Scholes inexplicably punched in the "equaliser" with a minute or two on the clock, he not only was given a second yellow and ruled out of the opening Champions League group game, but he also ended any chances of United getting an improbable draw.

Sir Alex Ferguson will spend the rest of the transfer window trying to sign a striker - probably Berbatov - but there are a few signs of concern. Striker or no striker, the midfield did not look very creative, and the defence is at its bare bones of experience. Wes Brown will be thrown back into team for the Liverpool and Chelsea games and Fergie must be praying for an injury free international break, otherwise our chances of winning the Premier League could be on the rocks by the end of September.

Ratings : van der Sar 6, Neville 5 (Brown 5), Ferdinand 5, Vidic 6, Evra 6, Fletcher 5 (Park 6), Scholes 5, Anderson 6 (O'Shea 5), Nani 5, Rooney 5, Tevez 7*

Tuesday, 26 August 2008

Yesterday's Chip Paper

A new series of articles I'm writing for (it's a great place, go check it out), is "Yesterday's Chip Paper", a look back on newspaper reports of yesteryear about Manchester United. The first takes a look at the late Emlyn Hughes hilariously bad prediction about the signing of Eric Cantona. Obviously he wasn't to know how it would pan out at the time, but even reading it now you'd be forgiven for doing a double take and wondering if his tongue was firmly in his cheek.

A Flashy Foreigner
EMLYN HUGHES on the last big gamble of United's Alex Ferguson - Daily Mirror, Saturday, November 28, 1992

It will be Oooh Arrgh Cantona

"A MASTER STROKE... that's what some people are saying about Manchester United's signing of Eric Cantona.

Me? I say it's a panic buy. One last frantic roll of the dice to see if the Frenchman can hit the jackpot for Alex Ferguson. It could either win him something this season, or cost him his job. Break the bank - or bust him.


And I'll admit when I heard the news I was simply staggered. Cantona looks the business, but in my opinion he's a flashy foreigner. He'll score goals for United... when they are two up. But don't look for him to get in there when it hurts, or to decide a game and be a matchwinner.

Cantona could have won the second leg of Leeds' European Cup tie with Rangers at Elland Road if he had been good enough. But he wasn't and he didn't. I counted a hat-trick of chances squandered before he knocked one in when the game was dead and buried.

United will want Cantona to produce the main meal of Boeuf Bourgignon, not just the appetizer of frogs legs and no filling. It might be all right for a month or two, but what will happen if Alex goes into one of his dressing room rages when things start to go wrong?


There have been allegations against the Frenchman that he shuffles off in a sulk when the flak begins to fly and has been training or even go home for two days. Don't forget he was trouble in France, where he fell foul of their authorities and was nicknamed L'Enfant Terrible. For Fergie to sign a player who looked as if he was being phased out at Elland Road, suggests he pushed the panic button. He failed to get Alan Shearer, who chose Blackburn instead of Old Trafford, then got no joy out of Sheffield Wednesday when he went in for David Hirst. Before that he sold off Mark Robins, who has since helped shoot Norwich to the top. So what he's done represents perhaps the biggest gamble of his career at the club.

I suspect Howard Wilkinson will get the best out of the deal.. the fact he's got his money back is sound business.

I'm always suspicious of crowd pleasers. Cantona had his fan club, and a chant, but it didn't mean he could play. Too often he didn't, when it mattered most to Leeds, like the two away European Cup ties he disappeared from. As Wilkinson said: "I can only play eleven players". What he didn't say was that Cantona was one of them.

Ferguson is becoming desperate in his quest to win the League for United, but his side ca't score goals.

I'm certain Cantona is not going to put that problem right. I cannot see him being the man who'll either get goals or start Mark Hughes scoring. Shearer was his man. Should have been, and Fergie is now getting stick from the fans for missing him. He has to expect it, and now he is forced to go clutching at straws. If United win the League it will prove to be the best buy of all... but if they don't...

Cantona is full of flair, he's flash, he gave Leeds something different and helped them win the title. Perhaps that's what has turned Ferguson's head. Perhaps he thinks what he's done one, he can do again.

It will keep his critics quiet on the terraces, and within the club.

But for how long?"

King Eric - decent player, but Emlyn reckoned Robins was the answer

King Eric.. decent player, but Fergie must still have sleepless nights at bringing him in and letting Robins go..

Portsmouth 0 - 1 Manchester United

Fletcher refused to give Rooney the secret of his golden boots (Picture = BBC)

An under strength Manchester United claimed a precious win at the notoriously difficult Fratton Park thanks to an own goal by ex-Manchester City defender Sylvain Distin.

Sir Alex Ferguson welcomed back Carlos Tevez, while Anderson returned from the Olympic Games (yesterday!) to ensure the continued loss of Ryan Giggs, and the absence of Owen Hargreaves and Michael Carrick, was not a blow.

United deservedly took the lead on 32 minutes when lovely work on the left hand side - a constant highlight of the first half - from Tevez and Evra saw the Frenchman's drilled ball go in off Darren Fletcher, Sol Campbell and Distin. Whose goal? Probably a Distin OG but Fletcher will be keen to claim the goal that would put him top scorer in the Premier League. It was just reward for the Scot's workrate in the first half - obviously buoyed by the backing he has from this website!

Brazilian Anderson fizzed in a wonderful pass that Rooney expertly controlled, turning, and firing just wide from 20 yards.

Anderson's logic defying fitness levels was perhaps of marginally less belief than referee Chris Foy's decision not to send off Papa Douba Diop when he punched the ball away from Wayne Rooney in the dying seconds of the first half - in fact, the Senegalese midfielder escaped any punishment whatsoever, just moments after receiving a yellow card. The scenario had yet to play its final scene as Diop again escaped any punishment in the dying moments of the match following a bad tackle on Tevez.

The second half was one of few chances but, again, United created arguably the better openings. There were many plusses for United, Evra's magic work down the left hand side, Brown and Fletcher in a very surprising confident combination down the right hand side, Possebon making an impressive cameo after the decision to rest Anderson after 70 minutes was greeted by boos from the United travellers, Rooney's impressive forward work, the fantastic defensive work of a patchwork Vidic, and of course the always understated work that is the genius of Paul Scholes.

United head into a mammoth double header with renewed optimism - and with the increasing body count being replenished, the cause for excitement can only grow.

Ratings : van der Sar 7, Brown 8, Ferdinand 8, Vidic 8, Evra 8, Fletcher 8, O'Shea 7, Scholes 8, *Anderson 9 (Possebon 7), Rooney 8, Tevez 8 (adapted by webmaster)

Sunday, 17 August 2008

Manchester United 1 - 1 Newcastle United

Manchester United 1 - 1 Newcastle United

The Premier League and European Champions suffered an eeriely similar fate as their last opening day fixture - being held to a home draw by less fancied competition.

Where last season's game was down to a credible defensive holding job by Reading, Newcastle comfortably stopped Manchester United taking the lead - and the injury list being increased would have done nothing to help the home fans optimism.

Already hampered by the loss of Carlos Tevez prior to kick off due to a family passing, United fans must have feared the worst to see a substitutes bench with no recognisable forward, and their fears would come to fruition. The first half started quite lively, as Magpies keeper was forced to make 3 super saves - first from a diving Fraizer Campbell header attempted from a sublime Wayne Rooney cross, and then from a low Rooney shot, from which Given parried a Scholes rebound. United had loud shouts for a penalty turned away when James Milner appeared to handle a third minute Ryan Giggs free kick.

Newcastle took the lead when Obafemi Martins expertly headed in a corner, but that lead lasted just 90 seconds as Darren Fletcher converted a magnificent Ryan Giggs pass to equalise. Giggs, on his 780th game, was by far the most imaginative United player on show and when he pulled up early in the second half, almost unable to use his left foot, any hopes of a home victory were more or less extinguished. The fear was compounded when in the 7 or 8 minutes he stayed on the pitch after, clearly uncomfortable and using only his right foot, he was clearly the main creative output. Indeed, it was a somewhat sad sight to see the Welshman hobbling about but head and shoulders above his team mates.

Giggs' injury followed the substitution of Michael Carrick, who went off after Fletcher's goal to be replaced by John O'Shea. Lacking half a first team of creative ability meant that a 1-1 result was only likely to be troubled by Newcastles energetic new signings - and although Vidic headed against the crossbar, and Rooney's last gasp freekick went past the post, there was a desperate sense of resignation amongst the home crowd. That Rafael, a right back, was introduced as an attacking hope for Fraizer Campbell with moments to go, was a telling story of the piece, and prompted flashbacks to John O'Shea's introduction as a striker in the Reading game of last season.

Once again United find themselves 2 points adrift of the rest of the "big 3" on the first day of the season with a daunting trip to Portsmouth, sure to apply themselves better after their comedic effort at Stamford Bridge, to follow. The collective absences of Ronaldo, Tevez, Anderson, Nani, Park, Saha, and the injuries to Giggs and Carrick will serve as rude awakenings to Red Devils - though with no improvement on the horizon, the Champions surely are already looking at a few months of catch up on their rivals.

Ratings : van der Sar 6, Brown 6, Ferdinand 6, Vidic 6, Evra 5, Fletcher 6, Carrick 6 (O'Shea), Scholes 6, *Giggs 8 (Possebon), Campbell 5 (Rafael), Rooney 6.

Sunday, 22 June 2008


Obviously I lost interest in this blog back in September but in January I became a contributor to (in my opinion) the best fan-run United website on the net, Much of that may be down to the respect that I have for the guy who runs it, and also due to the fact we tend to share the same opinions by and large on the club.

I intend to post all articles and major contributions that I make for the site on this blog, so as to extend my profile somewhat, as I also have launched a blog for the screenplay I have written, and to track the progess that it makes, if any.

In the meantime, I encourage readers to visit and also the blog for my screenplay, which will be available through my profile.